Women in high public office doesn’t mean equality throughout society: Justice Nagarathna
Justice B.V. Her remarks, reported by The Hindu, reverberated with a call for “substantive equality” – a principle that demands more than formal, uniform rights and insists on addressing the layered disadvantages that women from diverse backgrounds continue to face.
Justice B.V. Nagarathna, a senior judge of the Supreme Court who is poised to become India’s first woman Chief Justice, used the inaugural Cornelia Sorabji Memorial Lecture at Oxford’s Somerville College on 18 November 2026 to underscore a stark paradox: the presence of women in the highest echelons of public office does not automatically translate into gender equality across Indian society. Her remarks, reported by The Hindu, reverberated with a call for “substantive equality” – a principle that demands more than formal, uniform rights and insists on addressing the layered disadvantages that women from diverse backgrounds continue to face.
Formal Equality versus Substantive Equality
Justice Nagarathna distinguished between the veneer of formal equality – the legal right of a woman to hold a senior position – and the deeper, more demanding standard of substantive equality. She noted that a woman may occupy a top role while other women remain excluded from essential domains such as education, employment, property ownership, and effective legal remedies. This observation aligns with the broader Indian legal discourse that has long grappled with the gap between statutory provisions and lived realities.
In her lecture, the judge emphasized that “only the practice of substantive equality could take care of these differences among women hailing from and living through diverse life experiences.” By invoking the term “substantive,” she signaled that policy must be calibrated to the lived conditions of women across caste, class, disability, religion, region, and economic status, rather than assuming a one‑size‑fits‑all approach.
The Limits of Judicial and Legislative Action
Justice Nagarathna cautioned against over‑reliance on court judgments or legislative enactments as panaceas. She observed that a judgment cannot, by itself, guarantee safe workplaces, universal education for girls, lawful inheritance for women, or timely protection for victims of domestic violence. Similarly, legislation may falter if remedies remain inaccessible, public authorities fail to act, or entrenched social attitudes deter women from asserting their rights.
This critique resonates with the recurring challenges in Indian policy implementation. For instance, while the Supreme Court has struck down discriminatory provisions, the judge warned that such victories do not automatically reshape everyday experiences. The effectiveness of law, she argued, hinges on the operational capacity of institutions and the willingness of society to embrace change.
Constitutional Amendments and the Quest for Representation
The judge highlighted the recent constitutional amendment mandating that one‑third of seats in Parliament and state legislatures be reserved for women. She described this as a “proof to show that women should participate in decision‑making and not be content with just a formal right to vote.” The amendment, she noted, reflects an insight that historical exclusion has shaped institutional composition, and that formal equality alone may be insufficient to secure meaningful representation.
By drawing attention to this amendment, Justice Nagarathna linked the symbolic significance of quotas to the broader narrative of substantive equality. While quotas guarantee a minimum presence of women in legislative bodies, the judge implied that true empowerment requires that these women have the capacity to influence policy, which in turn depends on addressing intersecting barriers such as caste discrimination, economic insecurity, and limited access to education.
Violence Against Women: From Constitutional Recognition to Ground Realities
Justice Nagarathna observed that recognizing violence against women as a violation of constitutional rights has not yet translated into a world where women can seek protection without fear of stigma, retaliation, or economic insecurity. The gap between constitutional acknowledgement and effective enforcement remains a critical policy failure.
This gap is evident in the persistent under‑reporting of domestic violence cases and the limited reach of protection orders in rural and marginalized communities. The judge’s remarks underscore the need for a holistic response that integrates legal safeguards with social support systems, such as shelters, counseling services, and livelihood programs, to mitigate the economic fallout that often deters women from seeking justice.
Unpaid Care Work as a Structural Barrier
One of the most striking points in the lecture was the “disproportionate burden of unpaid domestic and care work” that women bear, which continues to shape their choices. Justice Nagarathna argued that this unpaid labor is a fundamental obstacle to gender equality, influencing everything from educational attainment to career progression.
The persistence of unpaid care work reflects deep‑rooted gender norms that policy must confront. Initiatives such as expanding public childcare, incentivising shared parental leave, and promoting flexible work arrangements can alleviate this burden. However, the judge’s emphasis suggests that without addressing these structural issues, formal measures—such as quotas or anti‑discrimination statutes—will have limited impact.
Intersectionality: Caste, Class, Disability, and Regional Disparities
Justice Nagarathna’s insistence that “there is no single experience of being a woman” foregrounds the intersectional nature of gender inequality in India. She noted that caste, class, disability, religion, region, and economic circumstances can profoundly alter the obstacles a woman encounters. Formal uniformity, she warned, cannot remedy intersecting structural disadvantage.
This perspective aligns with emerging research in Indian social policy that stresses intersectionality. For example, Dalit women face compounded discrimination that is both gendered and caste‑based, while women with disabilities encounter accessibility barriers that intersect with patriarchal expectations. Effective policy, therefore, must be nuanced, targeting specific vulnerabilities rather than assuming homogeneity among women.
Implications for Indian Policy and the Way Forward
Justice Nagarathna’s lecture offers a roadmap for policymakers, legal practitioners, and civil society. First, it calls for a shift from merely counting women in high offices to evaluating the substantive impact of their presence on broader gender outcomes. Second, it stresses the need for robust implementation mechanisms that ensure legal remedies are not just theoretical but practically accessible.
Third, the judge’s emphasis on unpaid care work and intersectionality suggests that future reforms must be multi‑dimensional. This could involve expanding social protection schemes, strengthening grievance redressal mechanisms for marginalized women, and investing in education and skill development programs that are tailored to the needs of specific groups. Finally, the lecture underscores the importance of cultural change—altering social attitudes that inhibit women from asserting their rights.
In sum, the presence of women in senior public roles, while symbolically powerful, is insufficient on its own to guarantee gender equality across India’s diverse social fabric. As Justice Nagarathna reminded the audience at Oxford, substantive equality demands a concerted effort that bridges legal provisions with lived realities, ensuring that every woman—whether a Supreme Court judge or a rural laborer—can claim her full constitutional rights without the weight of systemic barriers.
This article was produced with AI-assisted research and editorial support. Reporting is based on the source material cited below. Sources: The Hindu; thehindu.com; Global1.News (20 November 2026).
By Dr. Raj Patel, Staff Writer
What's Your Reaction?
Like
0
Dislike
0
Love
0
Funny
0
Wow
0
Sad
0
Angry
0
Comments (0)