Trump, Xi and Putin have a shared vision of global power – with no place for Europe | Rafael Behr
In an era where authoritarian powers are carving the globe into continental blocs, the recent three‑way summit in Shenzhen between President Donald Trump, President Vladimir Putin and President Xi Jinping starkly illustrates a realignment that marginalises Europe.
In an era where authoritarian powers are carving the globe into continental blocs, the recent three‑way summit in Shenzhen between President Donald Trump, President Vladimir Putin and President Xi Jinping starkly illustrates a realignment that marginalises Europe. The gathering, framed by the Chinese foreign ministry as a discussion on “safeguarding world peace” and “promoting strategic stability in major‑power relations”, was less about concrete policy outcomes than about the symbolic projection of a new power triangle. For observers of Sino‑American and Russian geopolitics, the event signals a convergence of three leaders whose visions of global order share a common thread: a diminished role for the liberal democratic West.
Historical Roots of the Authoritarian Bloc
The convergence of Trump, Xi and Putin can be traced to a series of diplomatic slights that have hardened the resolve of each leader to challenge the post‑Cold War liberal order. In 2014, former President Barack Obama’s description of Russia as a “regional power” provoked a deep sense of humiliation in Moscow. As the Guardian article notes, that remark “defined” Putin’s politics, fueling a “vengeful resentment” over the loss of super‑power status and a paranoid belief that NATO continues to undermine Russian prestige. This grievance remains a cornerstone of Russian foreign policy, informing its insistence on being treated as a “colossus of world history”.
Similarly, Trump’s worldview, as portrayed in the source, is driven by a “shallow, venal concept of power” that prizes “gilded palaces and heavily armed thugs”. His admiration for authoritarian leaders who operate without “equivalent restraint” aligns naturally with Xi’s ambition to cast China as the convener of a new world order. The three‑way summit, therefore, is less an ad‑hoc meeting and more a manifestation of a shared narrative that the United States, Russia and China are the true arbiters of global stability, while Europe is relegated to the periphery.
The Shenzhen Summit: Symbolism Over Substance
The agenda of the Shenzhen meeting was deliberately vague. While Chinese officials highlighted “world peace” and “strategic stability”, the specific topics listed by Trump—denuclearisation, Iran, trade and “my favourite subject, Ukraine”—revealed a mix of conventional security concerns and personal preoccupations. The Guardian piece emphasizes that the summit’s primary value to Putin was “the trappings of parity with the world’s two genuine superpowers”, a win irrespective of any substantive agreements.
Comparisons to the 1945 Yalta Conference underscore the anxieties such a gathering provokes in Europe. Yalta, remembered for its “cynical partition” of Eastern Europe, serves as a cautionary parallel: a small group of great powers shaping the fate of a continent without broader representation. The Shenzhen summit, held on the sidelines of a Pacific‑focused gathering, similarly excluded European democracies, highlighting a strategic insecurity that Europe’s continental allies have been unable to overcome despite repeated calls for inclusion in peace processes.
Europe’s Marginalisation and the Quest for Strategic Autonomy
European leaders have long warned that their exclusion from high‑level talks undermines their ability to influence outcomes. After recent peace talks in Abu Dhabi, Jared Kushner asserted that any deal “could not be done without Europeans being at the table”. By contrast, Russia’s chief negotiator, Vladimir Medinsky, dismissed European delegations as “tourists” who might as well “chat in the hotel bar”. This stark disparity in tone reflects a deeper reality: Europe’s institutional and economic foundations are under assault, and its capacity to project power is increasingly questioned.
The Guardian article notes that the EU’s ambition for “strategic autonomy” is a slow and costly process. Europe is transitioning from a soft‑power model—leveraging its single market and regulatory standards—to a more hard‑power posture that would require higher defence spending and a unified diplomatic voice. However, internal political dynamics, including divergent threat perceptions and domestic opposition to increased military budgets, complicate this evolution.
Britain’s Geopolitical Reckoning
Within the broader European context, the United Kingdom’s post‑Brexit trajectory illustrates the costs of diminished continental influence. Prime Minister Andy Burnham, in a recent speech, framed Brexit as “the first domino to fall” in a pattern of global fragmentation, arguing that Britain’s withdrawal from the EU has eroded its power and influence on the world stage. He warned that this “schism in European alliances” is precisely what authoritarian rivals desire.
Burnham’s critique resonates with observations from other British politicians, such as Kemi Badenoch, who speak of Britain’s “latent great‑power attributes”. Yet the Guardian source suggests that the reality of Britain’s diminished status is evident in its reduced ability to shape European decision‑making, a loss that cannot be compensated by a nostalgic belief in solitary great‑power status.
The Authoritarian Narrative of Power and Prestige
Both Trump and Putin share a perception that greatness is measured by the ability to dominate smaller nations and amass personal wealth. The Guardian piece describes Trump’s view of greatness as “the leader’s contempt for smaller nations and appetite for self‑enriching plunder”. This aligns with Putin’s desire for “parity with the world’s two genuine superpowers” and his expectation to be treated as a historical colossus. Xi’s role as the facilitator of the summit reinforces China’s self‑image as a central architect of a new order, further cementing the three‑way alignment.
These overlapping narratives reinforce each other: Trump’s admiration for authoritarian strength validates Putin’s quest for restored super‑power status, while Xi’s convening of the summit offers both leaders a platform to legitimize their visions. The convergence creates a feedback loop that marginalises liberal democratic norms and reshapes global power calculations.
Strategic Implications for the Future
The Shenzhen summit, while lacking concrete policy breakthroughs, carries profound strategic implications. First, it signals a coordinated front among the United States, Russia and China that can shape global agendas without European input, potentially redefining norms around security, trade and diplomatic engagement. Second, the exclusion of Europe from such high‑level dialogues deepens the continent’s strategic insecurity, compelling it to either accelerate its pursuit of autonomy or risk further marginalisation.
Third, the summit underscores the fragility of the liberal international order. As authoritarian leaders find common cause in projecting power and undermining NATO’s cohesion, the West faces a dual challenge: countering the narrative that liberal democracy is weak while rebuilding cohesive alliances capable of responding to a multipolar reality. Finally, the event highlights the importance for European policymakers to develop mechanisms that ensure their voices are heard in future multilateral settings, lest they become peripheral observers in a world increasingly shaped by a triad of authoritarian powers.
This article was produced with AI-assisted research and editorial support. Reporting is based on the source material cited below. Sources: The Guardian China; theguardian.com; Global1.News (20 November 2026).
By Prof. Marcus Chen, Staff Writer
What's Your Reaction?
Like
0
Dislike
0
Love
0
Funny
0
Wow
0
Sad
0
Angry
0
Comments (0)