Jewish Voices of Anti‑Zionism Reveal Deep Historical Rift
The conversation, recorded on 20 November 2026, traced the personal and political trajectories of figures ranging from a Dutch poet‑lawyer murdered in Jerusalem in the 1920s to contemporary artists and activists who have turned their criticism of Israel into a matter of conscience.
In a recent interview for Middle East Eye’s UNAPOLOGETIC series, Pulitzer‑Prize‑winning biographer Benjamin Moser opened a window onto a lesser‑known strand of Jewish history: the long‑standing opposition to Zionism that has run through the lives of twelve individuals over more than a century. The conversation, recorded on 20 November 2026, traced the personal and political trajectories of figures ranging from a Dutch poet‑lawyer murdered in Jerusalem in the 1920s to contemporary artists and activists who have turned their criticism of Israel into a matter of conscience. Moser’s reflections, anchored in his new book *Anti‑Zionism: A Jewish History*, illuminate how dissent has been rooted in religious, cultural, and ideological convictions, and why that dissent is now re‑emerging with renewed urgency.
The Method Behind the Narrative: Twelve Lives, One Question
Moser explained that he chose to structure his study around twelve distinct biographies because individual stories can reveal the nuances that broad statistics often obscure. By following the personal journeys of each figure, the book demonstrates how anti‑Zionist sentiment has been expressed in varied contexts—legal, artistic, religious, and revolutionary. This approach also underscores that opposition has never been monolithic; rather, it has emerged from divergent motivations that nonetheless converge on a common critique of Zionist ideology.
The interview highlighted that the selected lives span more than a hundred years, beginning with Jacob Israël de Haan, a Dutch poet and lawyer whose activism led to his assassination in Jerusalem in 1924. From there, the narrative moves through the 1940s schism within Houston’s oldest synagogue, the experience of Egyptian Marxist engineer Ahmed Sadiq Saad, the anti‑apartheid activism of Ronnie Kasrils, and the contemporary artistic protest of photographer Nan Goldin. Each case provides a lens through which to view the broader currents of Jewish dissent.
Moser stressed that the book does not aim to delegitimize Zionism per se, but to document a historically rooted counter‑current that has often been silenced or marginalized. By foregrounding these personal stories, he invites readers to see anti‑Zionism not as a recent political fad but as a thread woven through modern Jewish experience.
Early Dissent: Jacob Israël de Haan and the 1920s Turmoil
The earliest profile in Moser’s study is that of Jacob Israël de Haan, a Dutch poet and lawyer who arrived in Jerusalem during the British Mandate period. De Haan was a vocal critic of the growing Zionist settlement project, arguing that the influx of Jewish immigrants threatened the delicate demographic balance and the rights of Arab residents. His opposition was not merely political; it was also rooted in a religious conviction that the land’s future should be decided through inclusive, rather than exclusive, frameworks.
De Haan’s activism made him a target for Zionist militants. In 1924, he was shot dead in Jerusalem, an event that Moser describes as a stark illustration of how early Zionist groups sometimes resorted to violence against internal critics. The murder sent shockwaves through the Jewish diaspora, revealing the depth of division within the community at a time when the Zionist project was still consolidating its political and social foundations.
In the UNAPOLOGETIC interview, Moser linked de Haan’s fate to a broader pattern: the early suppression of dissenting voices that challenged the emerging nationalist narrative. He argued that this episode set a precedent for how internal criticism would be treated in later decades, especially as the Zionist movement grew more assertive and as the stakes of the conflict intensified.
The Houston Schism: A Post‑War Community Divided
Fast forward to the mid‑1940s, Moser turned to a different kind of conflict—one that unfolded within the walls of Houston’s oldest synagogue. The schism, which erupted in 1943, pitted a group of congregants who embraced a liberal, more inclusive vision of Judaism against those who adhered to a strictly Zionist interpretation of Jewish identity. The dispute centered on whether the synagogue should serve as a platform for political advocacy of the nascent Israeli state or remain a space focused on religious practice.
The split was emblematic of the broader tension between diaspora Jews who felt an increasing pressure to align unequivocally with Zionist aspirations and those who feared that such alignment would marginalize alternative Jewish voices. The disagreement spilled into communal life, affecting everything from liturgical choices to charitable initiatives, and it foreshadowed later debates within American Jewry about the relationship between religious identity and political loyalty.
Moser highlighted that the Houston episode demonstrated how Zionist unanimity could fracture even in places far removed from the conflict zone. The schism revealed that the pressure to conform was not limited to the Middle East; it resonated through Jewish institutions worldwide, shaping the contours of Jewish communal life for generations.
Marxist Roots: Ahmed Sadiq Saad’s Egyptian Experience
The interview then shifted to the story of Ahmed Sadiq Saad, an Egyptian engineer of Jewish descent who embraced Marxist ideology. Saad’s opposition to Zionism was intertwined with his broader anti‑colonial and anti‑imperialist convictions. Living in a post‑colonial Egypt, he saw Zionism as a nationalist project that privileged a single ethnic group at the expense of broader Arab solidarity.
Saad’s perspective added a critical dimension to the anti‑Zionist narrative: it linked Jewish dissent to left‑wing political currents that were simultaneously confronting colonialism, racism, and class oppression across the Middle East and North Africa. His experience illustrated how anti‑Zionist sentiment could arise from a synthesis of Jewish identity and broader revolutionary ideals, rather than from a purely religious or cultural critique.
In the conversation, Moser noted that Saad’s story underscores the intersectionality of oppression. For Saad, the fight against Zionism was part of a larger struggle against any form of domination that excluded or marginalized minorities. This framing resonates with contemporary human‑rights discourse, which emphasizes the interconnectedness of struggles for justice across different peoples and regions.
From Apartheid to Gaza: Ronnie Kasrils and Nan Goldin
The latter part of Moser’s book, as discussed in the interview, turns to two contemporary figures whose activism bridges historical anti‑Zionism and present‑day human‑rights campaigns. Ronnie Kasrils, a former South African anti‑apartheid activist, relocated to Israel and later became a vocal critic of Israeli policies, drawing parallels between apartheid in South Africa and the occupation of Palestinian territories. Kasrils argues that the structures of segregation, movement restrictions, and legal discrimination echo the apartheid system he once fought against.
Nan Goldin, an internationally renowned photographer, entered the anti‑Zionist arena after a personal encounter with the humanitarian crisis in Gaza. Goldin’s activism has been met with targeted smear campaigns, a point Moser highlighted when describing how dissenting Jewish voices are sometimes discredited through coordinated attacks. Goldin’s experience illustrates the personal cost of speaking out, as well as the power of artistic expression to mobilize public opinion.
Both Kasrils and Goldin embody a continuity of moral conviction that links past struggles against oppression with current opposition to policies deemed unjust. Their stories, as presented by Moser, reinforce the idea that anti‑Zionist sentiment can arise from a deep commitment to universal human rights, rather than from anti‑Jewish sentiment. This distinction is crucial in contemporary debates that often conflate criticism of Israel with antisemitism.
From Personal Evolution to Collective Rupture
Moser concluded the interview by reflecting on his own journey. Raised in Houston within what he describes as a “total Zionist unanimity,” he initially believed that Israel’s problems could be addressed through reform. Over time, however, his exposure to the histories of dissent and the lived realities of Palestinians led him to the stark conclusion that “Israel is the problem.” This personal transformation mirrors the broader rupture he perceives among Jews worldwide, a split that he believes will not be easily healed.
He argued that liberal Zionism has become a static position rather than a dynamic journey, suggesting that many who identify as “liberal Zionists” have ceased to engage critically with the evolving realities on the ground. The rupture, according to Moser, is not merely ideological but also generational, as younger Jews increasingly encounter narratives that challenge the moral foundations of the Zionist project.
The interview’s final moments addressed the contentious question of whether Zionism can be equated with racism. While Moser did not provide a definitive answer, he emphasized that the vocabulary of smears—terms like “anti‑Semitism” used to silence criticism—has become a central battleground. By documenting the historical depth of Jewish anti‑Zionism, his book seeks to reclaim space for legitimate dissent within the Jewish community and to remind the international audience that opposition to Israeli policies can be rooted in a long tradition of moral and ethical reflection.
By Fatima Al-Rashid, Staff Writer
This article was produced with AI-assisted research and editorial support. Reporting is based on the source material cited below. Sources: Middle East Eye video report (20 November 2026); Middle East Eye; Global1.News
What's Your Reaction?
Like
0
Dislike
0
Love
0
Funny
0
Wow
0
Sad
0
Angry
0
Comments (0)