UN commissioner warns of ongoing genocide as Israel targets Palestinian children

Sidoti, speaking with the outlet’s legal editor Sondos Asem, detailed the inquiry’s findings, challenged Western governments that have recognised the Rohingya genocide while hesitating on Gaza, and outlined the legal obligations that arise under the Genocide Convention.

Nov 17, 2026 - 15:52
0 1

In a stark interview recorded for Middle East Eye on 16 November 2026, UN Independent International Fact-Finding Mission on the Occupied Palestinian Territory Commissioner Chris Sidoti warned that the deliberate targeting of Palestinian children in Gaza and the West Bank amounts to an ongoing genocide. Sidoti, speaking with the outlet’s legal editor Sondos Asem, detailed the inquiry’s findings, challenged Western governments that have recognised the Rohingya genocide while hesitating on Gaza, and outlined the legal obligations that arise under the Genocide Convention. The interview, which forms the basis of this report, provides a sobering account of how children—some as young as two years old—have become systematic victims of a conflict that continues to reshape the lives of entire families.

Genocide still unfolding in Gaza, according to the UN inquiry

Sidoti opened the conversation by confronting the question of whether genocide is still occurring in Gaza. He affirmed that the inquiry’s evidence shows a pattern of intent to destroy, in whole or in part, the Palestinian national group, a core element of the crime of genocide. The commissioner emphasized that the ongoing nature of the violence, even after the ceasefire announced earlier this year, means that the genocide has not ceased.

He explained that the inquiry’s mandate, established by the UN Human Rights Council, required a systematic collection of evidence on the ground, including testimonies from survivors, medical records, and forensic analysis of impact sites. The findings, he said, demonstrate that the targeting of civilians is not incidental but part of a broader strategy that includes the deliberate killing of children.

Sidoti also highlighted the psychological impact on the surviving population. The loss of children, he noted, leaves a lasting scar on the community’s fabric, undermining the future of the Palestinian people and reinforcing the argument that the crime is aimed at the group’s existence.

Evidence of deliberate targeting of Palestinian children

The commission’s investigators documented numerous incidents where children were directly targeted. Sidoti recounted specific cases where children were hit by artillery shells, airstrikes, and sniper fire while playing, attending school, or simply walking to fetch water. He stressed that these attacks were not random; they occurred in areas known to be populated by families and were carried out with weapons capable of causing massive civilian casualties.

One of the most harrowing examples Sidoti cited involved a two‑year‑old child who was killed while his mother tried to shield him from a blast. “A two‑year‑old child is not a terrorist,” Sidoti said, underscoring the absurdity of any justification that frames such victims as combatants. The commission’s report includes forensic evidence linking the munitions used to the Israeli military’s arsenal, reinforcing the claim of deliberate intent.

Beyond the physical killings, Sidoti pointed to the systematic destruction of schools, playgrounds, and other child‑focused infrastructure. He noted that the inquiry found a pattern of strikes on facilities that were clearly marked as civilian, suggesting that the attacks were not merely collateral damage but part of a broader policy that disregards the protection owed to children under international humanitarian law.

How Israel justifies the killings and the inquiry’s rebuttal

When asked how Israel defends these actions, Sidoti described the official narrative that frames all casualties as the unfortunate result of Hamas’ use of civilian areas for military purposes. Israel, he said, argues that its forces are targeting legitimate military objectives and that any civilian deaths are incidental.

The commission, however, found that the proportionality principle—requiring that the anticipated military advantage outweigh the expected civilian harm—was repeatedly violated. Sidoti explained that the inquiry’s analysis showed that many attacks were disproportionate, with the expected civilian casualties far exceeding any plausible military gain.

Furthermore, Sidoti highlighted that Israel’s own statements often omit acknowledgment of the specific targeting of children. The commission’s report therefore concludes that the pattern of attacks cannot be reduced to a simple mistake or an unavoidable consequence of urban warfare; rather, it reflects a systematic approach that endangers children as a matter of policy.

International reactions and the Rohingya precedent

Sidoti turned to the reaction of Western governments, noting a stark double standard. He recalled that many of these states have formally recognised the genocide of the Rohingya in Myanmar, yet they remain hesitant to label the situation in Gaza as genocide without a court ruling. He questioned this selective application of the Genocide Convention, urging governments to act consistently with their own legal standards.

The commissioner explained that the Rohingya case, which has been brought before the International Court of Justice (ICJ) by Bangladesh, could serve as a legal precedent for the Palestinian case. He argued that the same legal arguments—particularly the duty to prevent genocide when there is a credible risk—apply to Gaza, and that the ICJ could be a venue for South Africa’s case against Israel.

Sidoti also addressed the criticism leveled by the United States and other states against the UN inquiry. He noted that some officials have accused the commission of bias and have sought to undermine its findings. Nonetheless, he maintained that the evidence gathered is robust, independent, and corroborated by multiple sources, making it resistant to political pressure.

The duty to prevent genocide before a court ruling

One of the most consequential points Sidoti raised concerned the legal duty of states to prevent genocide. Under the Genocide Convention, parties are obligated to act to prevent and punish the crime, even before a final judicial determination. Sidoti stressed that this duty is triggered by “credible evidence” of intent to destroy a protected group, which the UN inquiry has already established.

He warned that the failure of states to intervene—whether through diplomatic pressure, sanctions, or humanitarian assistance—constitutes complicity. Sidoti cited the commission’s findings that the ongoing targeting of children is a key indicator of genocidal intent, and therefore the international community cannot wait for a court decision to act.

The commissioner called on the United Kingdom, the United States, and other influential actors to align their policies with their own legal commitments. He highlighted that the UK, for instance, has recognized the Rohingya atrocities as genocide but continues to provide military support to Israel, a contradiction that Sidoti said undermines the credibility of its stance on international law.

Looking ahead: the inquiry’s next steps in the West Bank

Concluding the interview, Sidoti outlined the commission’s upcoming focus on the West Bank. He explained that while Gaza has been the epicenter of the recent violence, the West Bank also experiences systematic oppression, including the demolition of homes, restrictions on movement, and the use of lethal force against protesters, many of whom are children.

The next phase of the inquiry will gather evidence on the treatment of Palestinian children in the West Bank, assessing whether the patterns observed in Gaza extend to the occupied territories on the mainland. Sidoti emphasized that the commission will examine school closures, arrests of minors, and the impact of settlement expansion on the daily lives of children.

He urged the international community to monitor these developments closely, noting that the continuation of such practices could further solidify the case that genocide is not confined to a single geographic area but is part of a broader strategy to erode the Palestinian national group. The commission’s findings, he warned, will be presented to the UN Human Rights Council and could form the basis for future legal actions at the International Court of Justice.

By Fatima Al-Rashid, Staff Writer

This article was produced with AI-assisted research and editorial support. Reporting is based on the source material cited below. Sources: Middle East Eye video report (16 November 2026); Middle East Eye; Global1.News

What's Your Reaction?

Like Like 0
Dislike Dislike 0
Love Love 0
Funny Funny 0
Wow Wow 0
Sad Sad 0
Angry Angry 0
Fatima Al-Rashid

Gulf/MENA Correspondent at Global1.News. Based in Doha, covering Gulf politics, energy markets, diplomacy, and development across the Middle East and North Africa. Tracks the economic transformation of the Gulf states.

Comments (0)

User